Boss praises employee as a top performer but keeps him out of key meetings because he supposedly lacks industry knowledge: ‘Just read more’

Author image for Cata Holmes
Cata Holmes • Writer
Jun 25, 2026 11:15 AM EDT

What do you do when you're giving your best at work, but the opportunities never seem to follow?

Reading this story made me pause for a moment. I think most people who care about their careers have gone through a phase where they genuinely believed that hard work alone would be enough to get noticed. You put in the extra effort, volunteer for projects, help other teams, solve problems, and consistently deliver good results. Naturally, you start to assume that recognition and opportunities will follow. Unfortunately, that isn't always how workplaces operate.

What makes this situation especially frustrating is that the employee isn't imagining the positive feedback. According to the story, they've received good comments from executives, coworkers, and even their own manager. They're being trusted with important projects, creating presentations that reach senior leadership, and taking ownership of processes that impact multiple departments. From the outside, it sounds like someone who is doing everything right. That's why it's easy to understand why being excluded from key meetings and discussions feels so confusing.

That being said, I don't necessarily think this means the employee should start looking for another job immediately. Sometimes managers have blind spots. They genuinely believe they're protecting someone, helping them develop differently, or waiting until they feel they're fully prepared. Whether that reasoning is correct or not is another conversation entirely, but I think it's important not to jump straight to the conclusion that there's no future here.

I think the healthiest approach is to focus on what originally made the job enjoyable. If the work is meaningful, the team is generally supportive, and there are still opportunities to learn, it may be worth giving the situation one more chance before making any major decisions. After all, most people don't want more responsibility just for the title. They want it because they want to grow, contribute more, and become better at what they do.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A representation of a young professional working on a laptop.
    via Unsplash+ (via Getty Images)

    A representation of a young professional working on a laptop.

     

  • I joined this organization 6 months ago from a different industry. There are two established team members and one of them is very well versed about our industry (they've been in the organization for more than 2 years). A month after me, a new team member joined as well who is very bold and likes to insert themselves in conversations, they literally stare at people's screens and people joke about it too.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Since I've joined I've led process improvements across departments that went to the ceo, onboarded senior directors on a deck I made and presented to the, automated a process. I've gotten praise from senior stakeholders as well as others in different departments that it's very clear and easy, and that they thought it would be more complex.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • That being said, I've noticed that there is an informal team dynamic where they all get to work on presentations that go to C level executives while I'm shielded away. I've been told by others that I'm well spoken, present well, simplify complex concepts etc as well as being personable, friendly, and charismatic (according to my coworkers).
    via MembershipIll7920
  • That being said, recently my boss told me that I have everything he wants in an employee: leadership, ownership, dedication, strong work ethic, capability, critical thinking as well as punctuality but I need to have more domain knowledge about our industry. He told me you're doing very well and think about it as you at 90%, and that missing thread would push you to 95%.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • I agreed but I also pointed out that the lack of domain knowledge is because I'm often not included in these early stage discussions, meetings, and I find out about work later during the execution phase rather than early on. He had nothing to say.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • When I explained to him, how to get more of that knowledge? He said just read more which to me makes no sense because I could read the documents (already done that), but it's different than reality and what is being said in meetings.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Also the new team member doesn't have domain knowledge either (my boss himself brought it up) as an example of both of us not having domain knowledge yet she gets to present, and I don't.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Lately, my scope has been increasing and my boss asked me to create our entire department deck that would go to the COO, he also asked me to onboard our team members on the process I've been onboarding other departments on.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Should I even bother with this job or is there a de d end when it comes to my future in the organization? Am I just being sidelined?
    via MembershipIll7920
  • A representation of an employee reviewing projects from a home office.
    via Unsplash+ (via Getty Images)|

    A representation of an employee reviewing projects from a home office.

  • Redditors had a lot to say about this because this situation can feel very personal to all of us. While some of them were suggesting finding another job where the employee would feel more appreciated, others recognized that the boss's attitude is actually a huge green flag, since he wants the employee to be better and learn about the industry. What's your opinion on this story?

  • Exallium I think you should ask yourself "what do I need to do to get into that room" along with "do I want to be in that room to begin with". Like as a manager, imo part of their role is to help steer your growth as an employee.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Bubbafett33 He's not going to send someone with only six months' tenure at the company to represent him at the C suite. This is completely normal. Why? Because you could be brilliant, but when asked how the presentation content compares to something simple from two years ago, and you go "well, uh, I don't know the answer but I will get it", you will look like a fool in front of all the senior leaders.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • El-Poopy-Tray There should be a sticky post in this sub that tells all these high performers to just find a new job if they're not happy with their current role.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • retiredhawaii Do your best everyday. Make that your reputation. Consistently exceeds. That's a great thing to be known for. Be patient. If you're not recognized or don't feel your effort is appreciated after two years, then move on.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Annual_Particular_88 6 months at the company expecting full entitlement is honestly crazy Mate keep your great performance and things may (should) happen but corporate is not a speedrun
    via MembershipIll7920
  • THEFALLENANGEL I think a lot of younger people have a distorted timeline. A promotion every two years is good.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Unhappy-Homework-812 You need to get more hands on somewhere. Anywhere you can
    via MembershipIll7920
  • Appropriate-Gap34 Dude this is all green flag material. Your boss sounds like he deserves the space and grace required to position you successfully. As a business owner I have a larger scope and developing talent such as yourself sometimes requires a smidgen of patience and understanding. Keep asking questions but dont get married to little data points when there's a bigger picture you cant have access to yet.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • A representation of two business professionals shaking hands after a successful job meeting.
    via Unsplash+ (via Sebastian Herrmann)

    A representation of two business professionals shaking hands after a successful job meeting.

  • BallNelson Lip service. Watch what he does, not what he says. Get a new job.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • pmormr Remember there could be defensible reasons other people are getting to present that don't have anything to do with you. And it may not be appropriate to give you the full tea on that front. Just a hypothetical-- the CFO likes baseball. Your coworker also likes baseball. Boss knows their personalities will vibe having worked with both. Perfect person to task with presenting some financial update BS while you keep the rockstars focused on stuff that isn't BS.
    via MembershipIll7920
  • afty698 Have you asked your boss specifically why you aren't getting chances to present to the C suite, or maybe more politely, what do I need to improve to get those chances? It's hard to tell from your post whether the feedback about domain knowledge was specifically related to presentation opportunities or was just general feedback.
    via MembershipIll7920

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss employee work career workplace
Scroll Down For The Next Article